Compare EMDR and ART trauma therapies. Learn how each works, which conditions they treat best, and how to choose the right approach for your PTSD recovery.
When it comes to EMDR vs ART trauma therapy, understanding the differences can help you make an informed choice about your treatment. At Elevated Healing Treatment Centers, we offer both modalities—giving you access to the approach that works best for your specific trauma history.
Both EMDR (Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing) and ART (Accelerated Resolution Therapy) are evidence-based treatments for trauma and PTSD. According to the National Institute of Mental Health, trauma-focused therapies like these are among the most effective treatments available.
Eye Movement Desensitization Reprocessing
Eye movement desensitization reprocessing (EMDR) was developed by Dr. Francine Shapiro in 1987 and has become one of the most researched trauma treatments worldwide. During EMDR therapy, you focus on a traumatic memory while following the therapist’s fingers or a light bar with your eyes.
This bilateral stimulation appears to help the brain reprocess traumatic memories, reducing their emotional intensity. Research published by the American Psychological Association supports EMDR as a first-line treatment for PTSD.
EMDR typically involves 8 phases:
- History taking and treatment planning
- Preparation and establishing safety
- Assessment of target memories
- Desensitization through bilateral stimulation
- Installation of positive beliefs
- Body scan for residual tension
- Closure and stabilization
- Reevaluation in subsequent sessions
Trapped Trauma
Traumatic memories get “stuck” in the brain, triggering intense emotional and physical reactions whenever similar situations arise—keeping you trapped in survival mode.
Targeted Processing
Both EMDR and ART use specific protocols to help your brain process traumatic memories differently, reducing their emotional charge without requiring you to relive the trauma.
Freedom from the Past
After successful treatment, you can remember what happened without being overwhelmed by distressing emotions, physical symptoms, or intrusive thoughts.
Accelerated Resolution Therapy Benefits
Accelerated Resolution Therapy benefits include faster results and less emotional distress during sessions. ART was developed by Laney Rosenzweig in 2008, building on EMDR principles while adding techniques that may speed recovery.
What makes ART unique is the “Voluntary Image Replacement” technique—you actively replace disturbing images with positive ones while keeping the factual memory intact. This means you remember what happened, but the memory no longer triggers overwhelming emotions.
According to research cited by SAMHSA, ART has shown promising results in treating PTSD, often in fewer sessions than traditional therapies.
Evidence-Based Treatment Effectiveness
Source: Published clinical research meta-analyses
Find the Right Trauma Therapy
Our clinical team will assess your needs and recommend the most effective approach for your recovery.
Schedule Consultation Call: (747) 888-3000PTSD Treatment Comparison
When making a PTSD treatment comparison, consider these key differences:
Session length: ART sessions typically last 60-75 minutes with noticeable improvement often occurring within 1-5 sessions. EMDR usually requires 6-12 sessions for significant results, though complex trauma may need more.
Processing approach: In EMDR, you verbally share details of the trauma. In ART, you can keep trauma details private—the therapist guides the process without needing to know specifics. This makes ART appealing for those uncomfortable sharing details.
Emotional intensity: Both therapies are designed to minimize distress, but many clients report ART feels less emotionally overwhelming during sessions.
Rapid Trauma Processing Techniques
Rapid trauma processing techniques like EMDR and ART work by engaging the brain’s natural healing mechanisms. During both therapies, bilateral stimulation (eye movements or tapping) appears to activate memory reconsolidation processes.
At Elevated Healing, our trauma specialists are trained in both modalities, allowing us to:
- Match the therapy to your specific needs and preferences
- Switch approaches if one isn’t producing results
- Combine techniques when appropriate
- Integrate trauma therapy with other treatments like TMS
Frequently Asked Questions
Both can be effective for complex trauma. EMDR has more extensive research behind it, while ART may process memories faster. Our clinicians assess your specific situation to recommend the best approach.
ART often shows results in 1-5 sessions for single-incident trauma. EMDR typically takes 6-12 sessions. Complex or developmental trauma may require longer treatment with either approach.
With ART, you can process trauma without sharing details—the therapist guides you based on your internal experience. EMDR involves more verbal processing, though you control how much you share.
Yes, both are typically covered when provided as part of mental health treatment. We accept most PPO plans and Medicare. Verify your coverage with our team.
Begin Your Trauma Recovery
Expert EMDR and ART therapy at Elevated Healing. Joint Commission accredited. Medicare accepted.
Get Started Today 24/7 support: (747) 888-3000